Covered home entry with a limestone arch, oak door, paired glass sidelights and a mature live oak beside the porch.

Oysters, White Tablecloths and a Dress Code: Where Alamo Heights Dining Is Headed

The building at 1133 Austin Highway started as a Humble gas station. It later held a gourmet food store called Farm to Market. From 2012 to 2020 it was home to Nosh, an Italian restaurant led by chef Luca Della Casa. In 2022 that space became one of three La Fogata Mexican Cuisine locations. This fall the building is changing again. Silo, after 29 years upstairs, has moved to the ground floor as Silo Oyster Tavern. The upstairs room it left is meant for a dressier version of Nonna Osteria.

That one address sums up where Alamo Heights dining is going. Look at the projects announced along Broadway and Austin Highway between now and summer 2027 and most of them point upmarket. There's an oyster tavern, a white-tablecloth Italian room, a New York City-style oyster bar and a New Orleans-inspired chophouse with a dress code. Meanwhile one of the area's longest-running family Italian restaurants is moving north. The casual newcomers mostly come from Houston.

Silo goes downstairs and leans into oysters

The Express-News reported the Silo move on Oct. 13. The ground-floor menu now centers on fresh East Coast oysters, chosen daily. Silo's familiar dishes are still there: chicken-fried oysters, mussels, lobster mac and cheese, a lobster roll, a burger, blackened redfish, Parmesan-crusted chicken, beef tenderloin, and shrimp and grits. The 90-label wine list is staying. It helped put Silo on the paper's list of the top 10 restaurants in the 78209 ZIP code.

Here's how owner Patrick Richardson laid out the schedule in that report:

  • Dinner: from 5 p.m. seven nights a week at opening
  • With lunch added: 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday
  • With lunch added: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday

La Fogata isn't changing. Upstairs, Richardson describes the coming Nonna Osteria as a "white-tablecloth" version of the Italian concept he already runs at The Fairmount and on 1604, with Della Casa leading it. For Della Casa, it's a return to the building where Nosh ran for eight years.

Sorrento heads to Lockhill Village

Two and a half miles of Broadway away, the Italian news runs the other direction. Gino and Anna Ciccone opened Sorrento Pizza & Restaurant at 5146 Broadway in 2001. Their daughter Margherita now runs it. She also helped get the family's sauces onto H-E-B shelves in 2023. In September the family announced it would close the Broadway location and move to the Lockhill Village Shopping Center at 2311 NW Military Hwy.

MySA reported the restaurant's farewell post, which began:

"To our Alamo Heights family — thank you. For every celebration, every quiet weeknight dinner, every 'the usual, please,' and every face we've come to know and love over the years, we are endlessly grateful. This community gave Sorrento a home, and that means more to us than we can put into words."

The family said the recipes and the feel of the place would come along unchanged. Margherita told MySA the restaurant would close for a stretch during the move, possibly as short as a week and a half. For anyone who lives off Broadway, the new address puts Sorrento a short drive up toward Shavano Park. The trip is still easy, but it's no longer a quick walk-in on a weeknight. The restaurant's website lists the hours and has the latest on the new location.

Italian food isn't leaving the area. A family pizzeria from 2001 is leaving Broadway, and a white-tablecloth osteria is planned for Austin Highway.

The Nix building's second act is oysters and steak

The biggest project on Broadway is at 5307 Broadway, the former Nix medical clinic. According to MySA, the building had sat largely empty since 2019. Ridgemont Properties' early plans showed two restaurants without naming them. In February the Express-News reported that the incentive deal behind the redevelopment requires an operating restaurant there by 2027.

Now both restaurants have names. MySA reported on Oct. 3 that Dallas-based Vandelay Companies is bringing Hudson House and Jack & Harry's to the space. The group lists both in its hospitality portfolio. The two are quite different:

Hudson House Jack & Harry's
Style New York City-style oyster bar New Orleans-inspired chophouse
Menu highlights Oysters, raw bar, sushi, martinis Dry-aged steaks, Gulf seafood, New Orleans-inspired cocktails
Existing locations About a dozen in Dallas-Fort Worth One, in Dallas
Projected opening Late spring 2027 Summer 2027

MySA noted that Jack & Harry's has a dress code and seems to be the more formal of the two, though both lean toward the higher end. A construction filing with the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation shows an interior remodel for Hudson House running from Nov. 1, 2026, through April 30, 2027. The estimated cost is $1,675,250 for more than 6,500 square feet. So the work inside is already scheduled, and the late-spring target fits right after it.

Once Hudson House opens, the area will have two oyster-focused restaurants about a mile and a half apart: Silo Oyster Tavern on Austin Highway and Hudson House on Broadway. Before this fall it had neither.

The casual additions come from Houston

Most of the change points toward dressing up, but not all of it. The more relaxed newcomers are mostly coming from Houston.

Los Tios at 4820 Broadway. Houston's Adair Concepts is opening its first San Antonio Los Tios in the former La Madeleine. The Express-News reported that Alice Adair, wife of co-owner Nick Adair, grew up in Alamo Heights. The group had first expected to open in early 2025. In September the San Antonio Current put the opening in the fall. It pointed to the Fredericksburg location's menu as a likely guide: puffy queso, tostadas, tacos, fajitas, margaritas, beer and wine. The group's online ordering page already lists the Broadway address.

Tiny's Milk & Cookies at 5615 Broadway. In February the Express-News reported that this Houston bakery planned to open here by fall, led by chef and owner Baron Doke and president Bryant Dowd. The plan called for a walk-up window and scratch-made sourdough, pastries and cookies.

A Tex-Mex spot and a cookie window aren't trying to compete with a dress-code chophouse. They fill the everyday, weeknight end of the street, which is the role Sorrento played for 25 years.

The full map, by address

Here's everything above in one place, plus one more project at the north end of the corridor. Hours and opening dates change quickly, so check with each restaurant before you go.

Address Business Change
1133 Austin Highway, ground floor Silo Oyster Tavern Silo moved downstairs and reopened with an oyster menu
1133 Austin Highway, upstairs Nonna Osteria White-tablecloth version planned by Patrick Richardson
1133 Austin Highway La Fogata Mexican Cuisine No change
4820 Broadway Los Tios Adair Concepts' first San Antonio Los Tios, in the former La Madeleine
5146 Broadway Sorrento Pizza & Restaurant Moving to Lockhill Village, 2311 NW Military Hwy.
5307 Broadway Hudson House, Jack & Harry's Vandelay Companies; late spring and summer 2027
5615 Broadway Tiny's Milk & Cookies Houston bakery with walk-up window, announced in February
6333 Broadway Fulcrum Development building 14,000 square feet of retail and office space, including restaurant space

The last row is the farthest out. In August the Express-News reported that Fulcrum Development planned to start construction at 6333 Broadway in September. Senior vice president Ryan Bader said tenants were expected about a year after that. The building includes restaurant space, but no tenants have been named. On that schedule, the next restaurant to land on that stretch of Broadway would arrive close to the Vandelay openings at 5307.

If you'd like to talk through what's changing along Broadway and Austin Highway, or which part of 78209 puts you closest to the places you go most, I'm happy to help. Jen Romance has been helping San Antonio households since 2004. Let's Connect.

Work With Jen

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact her today.

Follow Me on Instagram